The game was quickly pulled from the few stores that stocked it. In some municipalities, it was banned outright. Mystique attempted to rebrand the game under a new label (Playaround) with tamer titles like Westward Ho , but the damage was permanent.
Today, Custer’s Revenge is a collector's morbid curiosity. A complete, boxed copy can sell for thousands of dollars, not because it is rare in the sense of lost art, but because so many original copies were destroyed by angry consumers. It occupies a unique space in gaming history: the "Holy Grail of Shovelware." game custer revenge